If you’ve been charged with a crime, chances are that the prosecution has suggested that you will receive a lighter sentence if you cooperate. They may have told you they will submit a "5K1 letter" to the judge urging him or her to impose a less severe punishment. Understanding what this is and what it entails is critical to getting a fair result. More importantly, you need to understand that the prosecutors are motivated by their own interests, and don’t necessarily care about what happens to you. The decision to cooperate with the authorities can have profound implications for you and the punishment you face.
Philadelphia criminal defense attorney Lauren Wimmer helps people charged with federal crimes get a fair result. She knows when cooperation can benefit you and when the prosecution is making empty promises that can jeopardize your future and your safety. If you’ve been charged with a federal crime and need someone on your side, contact Wimmer Criminal Defense Law at 215-712-1212 to schedule a free consultation to discuss your case.
In order to address widespread disparities in sentencing defendants convicted of federal crimes, Congress adopted the federal sentencing guidelines back in the 1980s. The federal sentencing guidelines use a number of factors to determine the punishment for a particular crime. These factors are plotted on the federal sentencing table, which then recommends a sentencing range. While the guidelines are not mandatory, judges must provide a written explanation when they choose to depart from the recommended sentence.
It may, therefore, seem that your situation is hopeless if you've been convicted. Fortunately, this is not the case - there are a number of instances that allow judges to deviate from the sentence recommended by the guidelines.
Section 5K1.1 of the federal sentencing guidelines allows judges to reduce a defendant’s sentence if the defendant has provided “substantial assistance in the investigation or prosecution of another person who has committed an offense.” However, the judge will consider the departure only “upon motion of the government.” In other words, the government must file a motion stating that you have rendered “substantial assistance” in prosecuting another person. The motion is made in the form of a letter submitted to the judge, typically referred to as a “5K1 letter” or a “5K1 motion.”
The 5K1 letter is merely the prosecution’s recommendation that your sentence be reduced - the decision will ultimately be made by the judge. That said, the sentencing guidelines do state several factors that the judge should consider:
The factors contained in the guidelines are not exhaustive. Rather, they are intended to answer the question of whether you provided “substantial assistance” to the prosecution. The judge will also consider the prosecution’s evaluation of the assistance provided, but again, is not obligated to take their evaluation as the sole determinative factor.
It’s also important to note that the 5K1 Letter should be filed only if you assisted in the prosecution of another person who committed a crime. This could include another person who was involved in the same incident that gave rise to your charges, such as a co-conspirator. It could also include another person who was involved in another completely unrelated crime. That said, cooperating with authorities regarding your own charges does not entitle you to a 5K1 reduction in your sentence.
Many people hastily decide to cooperate with the authorities only to later regret it. The prosecutors are not on your side - they want convictions. They may encourage your cooperation and use the information to pursue other convictions, only to later drag their feet in submitting your 5K1 letter. They may describe your assistance to the judge in less generous terms than you expected, even significantly devaluing your cooperation.
In addition, you or your family could face an ongoing risk of harm as a result of your cooperation. You may have to spend time in prison with people who know you cooperated with the authorities. Cooperation in gang-related charges can often put your family at risk if gang members learn that you helped convict one of their members.
You should also be aware that prosecutors may attempt to coerce you into cooperating. They may charge you with crimes you didn’t commit. They may tell you that you’ll receive an unrealistically harsh sentence unless you cooperate. While non-cooperation can lead the judge to increase your sentence, it’s important to understand that your cooperation or lack of cooperation does not guarantee any particular outcome.
The bottom line is that you should consider your options very carefully before you decide to cooperate with the prosecution. An experienced criminal defense attorney can explain your options, help you understand the potential consequences, and make sure that you receive a fair outcome if you do decide to cooperate. Your lawyer can also negotiate for certain protections for you and your family in exchange for your testimony. Your attorney will fight for your rights by making sure that the prosecution accurately describes your cooperation and arguing for fair consideration when it comes time to determine your sentence.
Don’t let the prosecution persuade you to cooperate with unrealistic promises of leniency. If you’ve been charged with a crime, the best thing you can do is speak with a criminal defense attorney as soon as possible. Philadelphia criminal defense attorney Lauren Wimmer can help you understand your options and get a fair result. Call us at 215-712-1212 or visit us online to schedule a free consultation to learn more about how we can help.